Welcome to
Carter And Company
Chocolatey Cakes
Brooklyn Blackout Cake
Super chocolatey and one of our best sellers.
Extra Moist and flavorful Chocolate Cake Layers, alternating with chocolate pudding, then coated in pudding and crumbs.
Caramel Cake
The same moist chocolate layers, sandwiching caramel buttercream, more caramel buttercream on the outside and a pool of caramel on top!
Peanut Butter Cake
Chocolate Layers filled with caramel, peanut butter and cream cheese, iced with cream cheese peanut butter frosting and topped with nuts, ganache and caramel drizzle.
German Chocolate Cake
Filled and topped with our housemade German Chocolate Custard filling, loaded with pecans and coconut for the classic cake invented by Samuel German in 1852.
Chocolate Flourless Cakes
Some cakes are flourless - and therefore Gluten Free - by their nature.
This is the type of flourless cake we offer.
There are ganache-based truffle cakes, decorated simply with a white chocolate mousse and chocolate shavings.
We also have an almond flour based gluten free cake.
Typically you need to order these ahead - they don't sell as fast as they need to in order to keep them on hand.
Pricing
Cakes are made in 9 inch round.
Most cakes are 39.50 for a whole cake (specialty cakes are more)
or by quarter or half cakes in a box.
When we can put a slice of cake on a plate or a box for you we weigh it, so you can get as large or small a piece as you want.
Fruity Cakes
Orange Curd Cake
Super flavorful Orange Cake, made moist with Olive Oil (Yes!) (and No, it doesn't taste like olive). Coated with ganache. Filled with Homemade Orange Curd.
(Curd tastes better than it sounds. For the uninititated, it is simply a custard of orange, egg yolks, and butter, thickened over heat.)
This has been one of our most popular flavors for a couple of years.
Lemon Drop Cake
Same cake recipe as the Orange, only made with Lemon and filled with homemade Lemon Curd. Iced with Lemon Buttercream, which, along with all our buttercreams,
is made in the shop with real butter
Almond Cake And More
Now that we have found a white cake that lives up to our expectations of moistness and flavor, we can use it to make this almond cake, or fill it with raspberry (or any other) jam, and coat it with our real butter buttercream with a complimentary flavor.
The flavor combinations are endless, and yours can be topped with white chocolate mousse and berries in season.
Carrot Cake
Our carrot cake has Pineapple and Coconut added, and is filled and iced with our orange-caramel cream cheese icing, then topped with a pool of white ganache.
It looks and tastes divine!
Specialty Cakes
Specialty cakes are standard ones that take significantly longer to make, from making extra fillings and icings to the cake itself and the assembly; or special order cakes that need moe attention than just writing "Happy Birthday Mom!"
Special orders can be taken over the phone, but might be better in person if there are lots of details.
360 876 4424.
Payment is taken when orders are placed.
Lime Cake
This is the same recipe as the Lemon and Orange, only made with Lime.
there are three fillings: Orange curd, Pineapple Buttercrema and coconut Pastry Cream.
then it is iced with Rum Buttercream and decorated with coconut.
Hazelnut Cake
Layers of hazelnut buttercream and Kahlua buttercream, iced with both.
Specialty decorated cakes
We are the place to go for delicious, moist, flavorful cakes made from scratch with elegent decorations.
Any cake you like can be turned into a Galaxy Cake, and we can build a special fondant cake for you.
We have limited time for tiered wedding cakes or for cakes with movie heroes or cartoon characters. :(
Cheesecakes
New York Cheesecakes
John's New York cheesecake recipe is pretty traditional. This is a more substantial cheesecake than our fruit ones, with a hint of lemon in the crust as well as the cake itself.
These are 8 inch round cheesecakes and can be special ordered. Often we will have them whole or by the slice when you stop in, but not always, so it is best to order ahead!
Mini cheesecakes
We have a selection of mini cheesecakes every day.
Just enough for one hungry person, but often shared by two, these are usually available with either blueberries, raspberries, or caramel.
We make them fresh almost every day, so if you order ahead we can usually make you a plain one, or Amaretto. We are happy to do other flavors in large quantities.
An assortment of these is a great dessert for a group! Folks often bring a few mini cheesecakes along with a few tarts to gatherings.
Large fruit, berry, or liqueur cheesecakes.
Order ahead for specialty cheesecakes.
Very popular choices are Bailey's, Amaretto or Kahlua cheesecakes along with berry.
Pumpkin Cheesecake season lasts from October thorugh December.